Creamsicle Cookies

 

A couple years ago I received a wedding invitation in the mail from my friend Ellen, who I had met at school in London. She was getting married in Northern California; I was missing her and my other school friends, plus I had a new disposable income, so I decided "what the hell, I'll go to California."

I booked myself a room at a motel in Menlo Park, and since I wasn't set to meet up with my friends until the next day, I set out to explore. First stop, Trader Joe's, where I stocked up on fresh strawberries, peaches, and avocados to stash in my motel mini fridge. This would be 90% of my diet for the trip (can you blame me??) 

From the walkway outside my motel room. I kinda wanted to just stay there forever.

My next priority was to go to Safeway to see what kind of crazy American junk food I could get. I clearly have my priorities straight, as you can tell. It was a little eerie walking through the Menlo Park Safeway because, being a chain, it looked almost identical to the Safeway back home, except one major difference: there was more. Just more of everything. More varieties of cereal, more flavours of Clif Bars, more produce, more everything. And, most importantly, more kinds of Oreos. 

They had Oreo flavours I'd never dreamed existed (Berry Burst Ice Cream Oreos, anyone?), and the ones I got most excited about were the Creamsicle Golden Oreos. I bought a box and told myself I'd take them home to share with others. 

Ha! Silly Lindsay! As if I could have a package of Creamsicle Oreos in my motel room for 3 days without eating almost all of them. I had such high hopes for myself, but alas, I am an incorrigible cookie fiend. 

So yeah, I ate almost all of them over the course of a few days. But I still fit into the dress I brought for the wedding, so whatevs. 

Walking under an orange tree on my way to meet up with my friends.

That trip - the sunny lusciousness of California in August, the happiness of seeing my friends again, the dizzy romance of watching Ellen get married on a gorgeous summer night - it makes me sigh just thinking of it. Can you fall in love with a place, the same way you would with a person? I think I kinda did. 

Orange Creamsicle Oreos
Makes about 25 cookies

Cookies
1 cup butter, softened
1/2 granulated sugar
1 tablespoon vanilla extract
2 cups all purpose flour

Orange Buttercream Filling
1/2 cup butter, softened
2 cups icing sugar
Zest from 1 orange
1-2 tablespoons orange juice
A couple drops of orange food colouring (optional)

To make the cookies:

1. Preheat the oven to 350°F/180°C and line two baking sheets with parchment paper.

2. In a mixer, cream together the butter and sugar until light and fluffy; beat in vanilla. On low speed, add the flour and mix just until combined. The dough will be slightly crumbly.

3. Form the dough into a ball on a lightly floured surface and gently knead a couple times to create a smooth, uniform dough. Flour a rolling pin and roll the dough out to about 1/4-inch thickness. Using a floured shot glass or a 2-inch round cookie cutter, cut as many circles out of the dough as you can.

4. Transfer the dough circles to your prepared baking sheets and bake for 10-12 minutes, until the cookies are lightly golden on the bottom. Allow to cool completely on a rack.

To make the filling: 

1. Beat the butter for about a minute to get it nice and creamy, and start adding the icing sugar gradually, beating until smooth.

2. Add the zest, orange juice, and food colouring and beat until smooth. If needed, add more juice or icing sugar to adjust the consistency and get a creamy, spreadable buttercream.

To assemble:

Use a spoon or piping bag to get about a tablespoon of buttercream onto the bottom of a cookie, then squish another cookie on top. Keep chilled if it's warm out; these are best enjoyed a few minutes after coming out of the fridge.

 

Millionaire's Shortbread

Can you think of anything more boring than having to go to a philosophy seminar on a Friday afternoon, after a long week of classes and assignments and trying to make sense of the dry, dry texts you were supposed to read? Then, even worse, having to discuss those dry texts, trying desperately to sound like you have a clue about what's going on. That's how I felt before I had my first Friday seminar when I was going to school in London a few years ago - total dread.

... But then I actually went, and it wasn't that bad. We were just a small group of girls having a conversation for a couple hours before the weekend. Our instructor was awesome and made us feel like there were no stupid questions, and gently led us in meaningful, interesting conversations. I started to really look forward to Friday afternoons. It didn't hurt, of course, that we all started bringing wine and chocolate and cookies to these little seminars of ours.

Keep reading »

Fresh Mascarpone with Balsamic Cherries

Recently I took a Continuing Education course at NAIT called "Young Cheesemaking Fundamentals" - after attending Eat Alberta in April, I knew I wanted to come back to the NAIT kitchens as soon as I could. Chef Allan Roote welcomed our tiny class and got started right away. There were only eight of us, which I thought was perfect, as there was lots of hands-on learning and we could easily crowd around Chef Allan and watch his demos closely. Over the course of the night, we tasted and made yogurt, mascarpone, ricotta, mozzarella, and cheese fondue.

Keep reading »

Duck Egg Sponge Cake with Rhubarb Compote and Cream

  

One of my very favourite things is receiving unexpected food gifts... I swear I'm not trying to sneakily demand presents, I'm just stating a fact! The last time my mom came to visit, she brought homemade apricot jam and beef from my uncle's farm. Beautiful! My dad often brings artisan sausages back from Saskatchewan when he visits, and I've gotten some pretty nice treats from my brother and sister when they've come back from travelling. People must just think, "Lindsay likes food" and assume it's a safe bet ...and they are correct. ;)

Keep reading »

French Coconut Pie with Dark Chocolate Sauce

 

I've been wanting to dedicate a post to Paris for a while now, but just never got around to it. I didn't know what to make, since most of what I ate when I was there was cheese and fruit and more cheese. Then finally it dawned on me: the first night we were there we ate at Le Café du Marché near the Eiffel Tower, and although our dinner was rich and kind of "meh", we split the most delicious coconut pie with the darkest, blackest chocolate sauce I'd ever tasted.

My friend (and then roommate) Christina and I went on a little trip to Paris in September 2011 to celebrate finishing our theses and finally being done with school. As soon as we stepped off the train, I immediately understood what all the fuss was about. Paris is magical. I was swept off my feet.

Keep reading »

Brown Sugar Shortbreads with Bailey's Crème

 

Let's call a spade a spade: these are just boozy Girl Guide cookies. I used to be a Girl Guide myself, and I loved it when springtime rolled around because that meant chocolate/vanilla cremes, and the vanilla ones were my favourite. Even though I was supposed to be going door to door selling them, a box or two would inevitably end up getting eaten at home. As an adult, I still get excited when someone at my office brings in a case to sell. 

Keep reading »

Creamy Lime and Avocado Pie

This post is dedicated to the very, very tiny voice of virtue in my head, the one who every once in a while shouts at me to eat something clean and healthy. Sometimes you crave a cheeseburger, and other times you need something devoid of animal fats, processed sugar, and other things that are probably not great for you. Luckily, I live near Noorish Conscious Eatery, which caters to my occasional bouts of virtuousness with an eccentrically delicious menu.

Keep reading »

Banana Chocolate Chip Doughnuts with Peanut Butter Glaze

I don't know about you, but whenever I buy a bunch of bananas, I can never seem to finish eating all of them before they get too ripe. I do like my bananas a bit on the unripe side, so maybe my criteria for bad bananas is a little too harsh. Luckily, there are a million delicious recipes that use up over-ripe bananas... in fact, maybe I just let them get that way because my subconscious craves banana bread. My subconscious effing loves banana bread.

Keep reading »

Coconut Bread

Sometimes when I'm visiting the home of a friend or family member, I'll take a sneaky peek at their cookbook collection and - if I'm feeling really sneaky - I'll snap photos of some of the recipes with my phone so I can make them later. What's the point of me buying a new cookbook if I can just creepily take pictures of yours when you're not looking?

So we went to visit my boyfriend's mom in Calgary recently... and long story short, I have a lot of pictures of cookbook pages on my phone now. My favourite book to look at when I'm at her house is Donna Hay's Seasons because like all of Donna Hay's other books, it's filled with pretty pictures of simple and interesting food. This recipe for coconut bread caught my eye right away.

Keep reading »

Pistachio Macarons

Recently I've had a string of okay-but-not-great baking experiences, using recipes I found online. I'm usually pretty discerning with recipes I find on the internet - I pay close attention to ratings and comments, and I'll rarely use one that has no feedback at all. But I just wasn't having great luck. The things I made weren't bad, per se, but I wouldn't take the time to make them again. So after those disappointments, I decided to hit the books - cookbooks, that is.
Keep reading »

Sour Cherry & Almond Tarts

Once I get the first whiff of spring, I immediately want to do the following, all day every day: 1) stroll along Whyte Ave, coffee in hand; 2) sit on a patio, any patio, and get day-tipsy; and 3) go to the farmers' market, namely the Old Strathcona Farmers Market. The Strathcona market is great because it's indoors, so even if you have premature spring fever and it's still -10 degrees outside, you can get that lovely market experience without freezing your buns off. 

We went to the Strathcona market a few weeks ago, and it was packed with equally eager market-goers. Among the goodies I picked up was a bag of frozen sour cherries from Rainbow Acres farm. I can never find cherries in the grocery store that aren't candied or swimming in sugar, so this was exciting. Real cherries are such a rare treat. Plus these were already pitted! Since then I've browsed what feels like hundreds of cherry recipes, until I finally landed on this cherry almond tart from the Joy of Baking. It was a tough decision, but someone had to make it. 

Keep reading »

Incredibly Chewy Maple French Toast Cookies

 

Allow me to introduce Attempt #2 in my quest for a copycat of Bloom Cookie Co.'s maple french toast cookie. Damn you, Bloom, for making your cookies so unattainably delicious! (But please don't stop whatever you're doing. It's amazing).

I decided to try my hand at these again (attempt #1 can be found here) because I bought a package of maple french toast Blooms at Remedy on Friday, and I remembered how crazy good they are. Plus it's March, which means it's sugaring off season down east, which means MAPLE TIME. AKA, the most wonderful time of the year.

Keep reading »

Perfect Chocolate Chip Cookies

There are few things better in this world than a really, really good chocolate chip cookie. Everything about them, from the dough (not ashamed to admit I eat it!), to the smell of them baking in the oven, is classic and comforting and delicious. And biting into a chocolate chip cookie warm from the oven... that's pretty hard to top in terms of heart-melting goodness.

My mom has used the same chocolate chip cookie recipe for years (scrawled on a piece of loose leaf by a co-worker) and I've adopted it as my gold standard cookie recipe. But recently I was listening to the chocolate chip cookie episode of my favourite food podcast, Spilled Milk, and they brought something to light that I didn't know before: chilling the dough for at least 24 hours will result in much, much better cookies. Chilling the dough, they explained, allows the sugars to get completely absorbed by the liquids, and the cookies turn out soft and chewy with a richer flavour - kind of toffee-like. Apparently, even the original Tollhouse chocolate chip cookie recipe called for chilling the dough overnight - a step that for some reason has been left out of the famous package instructions. 

Keep reading »

Salted Caramel Brownies

 

I don't make New Year's resolutions. Maybe I should, but I just can't be bothered... especially since January has got to be the worst time to summon the motivation to go for a run or cut back on carbs. January/February is the time of year when I feel like napping, eating warm things from the oven, and watching every season of Friday Night Lights.

It was that kind of a weekend about a year ago when we visited my boyfriend's mom in Calgary. We kind of just stayed in, ate good food, cuddled with her dog and watched SNL. It was so nice. She had made a pan of Ina Garten's salted caramel brownies and we nibbled on them all weekend (and for a while afterwards, since she packed them up and sent them with us).
Keep reading »

Cinnamon Bun Bars (and New Beginnings)

I'm back! Sorry for the long hiatus. The past few months have been a whirlwind - from a conked-out oven and a pest infestation, to finding a new apartment (new oven, no pests), escaping to Cuba for a while, Christmas, et cetera, et cetera... it's been a crazy winter! But we're all moved in, the tumult has died down, and I've got a new Kitchenaid mixer and camera (squeeeee!!) so I have no good reason for not posting! I hope all of you had lovely holidays and are managing to stay cozy and warm, wherever you are.

Keep reading »

Soft Maple Cinnamon Cookies

There are few things that smell better on a dreary October day than something cinnamony baking in the oven. Add maple to the mix and you'll have the most comforting aroma that ever wafted through a kitchen.

I have been trying to recreate a cookie that I bought from Bloom this summer - a soft, maple french toast flavoured treat. [Note: if you haven't had Bloom cookies yet, keep your eye out for them. They can be found at the City Market downtown and at all three Remedy locations. Their cookies are always soft, chewy, and totally addictive. If you can find the London Fog cookies, buy them and eat them before someone else does!]


Keep reading »

Carrot Cake with Lime Mascarpone Icing

 

It was my mom's birthday this past weekend, and I wanted to bake her a cake. And, it being fall, I've had a craving for a spicy, hearty carrot cake with mile-high icing on top. Luckily, I had just the right amount of mascarpone and cream cheese left over from making nectarine & mascarpone tarts, so it worked out perfectly. There's something about the combination of warm spices, earthy carrots, and cool, silky cream cheese icing that's so comforting. It's one of the best parts of fall.

Keep reading »

Nectarine, Mascarpone & Gingersnap Tartlets

It's nectarine season, and ohhhh man are they good. You think you know what nectarines taste like... and then you take a big, juicy bite out of some ripe in-season fruit and your brain explodes from the sweet, gorgeous flavour party in your mouth. You basically have to make out with one of them to keep the juices from dripping all over you, but they're so insanely good that it's totally worth looking a bit vulgar while you eat. 

Anyway, I picked up a basket of perfect nectarines from Steve & Dan's fruit stand at the 124th Street Grand Market last week, and have been gorging on them ever since. While I mostly just eat them whole, I wanted to make something special with them - a celebration of nectarines - and make sure the internet knows how inappropriately in love I am with this fruit.

Keep reading »

Extra Chocolatey Zucchini Loaves

I'm not lucky enough to have my own garden (and even if I did, I don't have a very green thumb), but last week I found out I am lucky enough to work in an office with some gardeners. I love it when people come in with surplus rhubarb or apples or, in this case, zucchinis. Then, after I've gone home and turned perfectly healthy fruits and veggies into sweet, sweet desserts, I can bring the finished product in to share with my co-workers. It's the circle of life... or secondary industry... or something.
Keep reading »

Peanut Butter Sandwich Cookies

I’m back! Sorry for the long hiatus – I’m blaming it on spotty internet service, a long and much-needed vacation, starting a new job, and generally enjoying summer too much. The last month or so has been a whirlwind of catching up with friends and family, going camping in Kananaskis, and spending a whole lazy week in the sun at Lake Windermere. It’s been a busy but lovely summer so far.

We went for a hike in anticipation of the calories to come.

 

Anyway! I come bearing cookies! Big, soft peanut butter sandwiches – a creamy filling squished between two chewy PB cookies. These are for hardcore peanut butter lovers only.

I made a big batch of these to bring on our camping trip in Kananaskis. There were almost thirty people there – a whole side of my boyfriend’s extended family – so I wanted to bring a crowd pleaser. And who doesn’t like peanut butter, amiright? I got the recipe from Sweet Pea’s Kitchen (where the cookies and photos are markedly prettier, haha) and have made it a few times; the cookies always receive great feedback – mostly “Mmm”s and “Omgahhh”s and “Mrrumnumnum”s.

Keep reading »